The thought that won’t stop

Rumination, in six steps: the moment as it is experienced, and what the brain’s networks are doing at the same time.

Every step has both. The science view adds the strength of evidence and references.

The 3D view is not available on this device.

Outside · the moment · drag to rotateStuck loop
DepressionRecovery
Inside · the brain’s networks · drag to rotate
1 / 6
  1. Step 1 of 6

    The same thought, again.

    A friend is talking and holding out a cup of tea. The words arrive, but attention is somewhere else, replaying one thought.

    This is rumination. It feels like working on a problem. In practice it is a thought that cannot finish.

    The picture above the model is the moment. The dark ring around the listener’s head is the thought going around.

    Rumination as a response style

    Well established

    Rumination is repetitive, passive focus on one’s distress and its causes and consequences. In prospective studies it predicts the onset, severity and duration of depressive episodes, and it is distinct from active problem solving.

    1. Nolen-Hoeksema 2000, J Abnorm Psychol
    2. Nolen-Hoeksema, Wisco & Lyubomirsky 2008, Perspect Psychol Sci
  2. Step 2 of 6

    The brain’s inward network.

    When the mind turns inward, to memories, plans or thoughts about ourselves, a set of connected areas becomes active.

    In a healthy day this network switches on and off. A thought comes, gets its turn, and passes.

    In the model, beads travel around a loop of three areas. Here the loop is slow and calm.

    The default mode network

    Well establishedSimplified model

    The default mode network (DMN) includes the medial prefrontal cortex, posterior cingulate cortex and precuneus, and lateral parietal and medial temporal regions. It is most active during rest and self-referential thought and is suppressed during externally focused tasks. The subgenual cingulate is not a core DMN hub; it is shown here because of its role in depression.

    1. Raichle et al. 2001, PNAS
    2. Buckner, Andrews-Hanna & Schacter 2008, Ann N Y Acad Sci
  3. Step 3 of 6

    In depression, the loop gets stuck.

    The inward network becomes more tightly tied to an area involved in low mood. The same thought keeps its turn.

    People describe knowing the thought is unhelpful and being unable to set it down. That is the loop, not a weakness of will.

    In the model, the loop is now fast and bright, and it does not let go. In the picture, the head is bowed and the ring is closed.

    DMN and subgenual hyperconnectivity

    Human imaging studiesVariable across studies

    Meta-analytic work links depressive rumination to increased functional connectivity between the DMN and the subgenual prefrontal cortex, and large-scale analyses find DMN hyperconnectivity in major depression. Effect sizes are modest, findings vary with method and sample, and connectivity measures do not diagnose an individual.

    1. Hamilton et al. 2015, Biol Psychiatry
    2. Kaiser et al. 2015, JAMA Psychiatry (meta-analysis)
    3. Sheline et al. 2009, PNAS
  4. Step 4 of 6

    The part that changes the channel.

    Another area, toward the front and side of the brain, helps shift attention: from inside to outside, from one thought to the next.

    In depression its signal is often weaker, so the loop runs without interruption.

    The blue area and the blue pathway are this control signal. Here it is faint.

    Frontoparietal control and network switching

    Human imaging studiesSimplified model

    The dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) is part of the frontoparietal control network, which supports shifting between internally and externally directed attention. Depression is associated with hypoconnectivity within this network, and greater DMN dominance over task-positive networks tracks higher maladaptive rumination.

    1. Hamilton et al. 2011, Biol Psychiatry
    2. Kaiser et al. 2015, JAMA Psychiatry (meta-analysis)
  5. Step 5 of 6

    What treatment aims to do.

    TMS is placed over that control area. The spot is chosen because it connects to the deeper area the loop runs through.

    The aim is not to stop thinking. It is to let a thought finish and pass. Ketamine, esketamine and some forms of therapy work toward the same end by other routes.

    In the model, a TMS coil sits over the control area. Its signal strengthens, and the loop begins to slow.

    Treatment and the default mode network

    Early clinical evidenceMechanism not settled

    Clinical efficacy of left DLPFC TMS targets relates to their negative functional connectivity with the subgenual cingulate. In a small study, a course of TMS normalized depression-related subgenual and DMN hyperconnectivity. Ketamine reduces DMN connectivity in healthy volunteers. Rumination-focused cognitive behavioral therapy reduced residual depression in a randomized trial. Whether network change causes symptom relief is not established.

    1. Fox et al. 2012, Biol Psychiatry
    2. Liston et al. 2014, Biol Psychiatry
    3. Scheidegger et al. 2012, PLoS One
    4. Watkins et al. 2011, Br J Psychiatry
  6. Step 6 of 6

    Attention comes back to the room.

    As the loop loosens, thoughts still come. They also go. The head lifts, the friend’s words land, and a hand reaches for the cup.

    Noticing the loop and turning toward what is in front of you is a skill. It gets easier with treatment and with practice.

    Move the slider under the picture, or press Play, to see the two change together.

    In the model, the loop is calm and green and the control signal is strong. In the picture, the ring has opened and drifted away.

    Practice alongside treatment

    Well establishedSimplified model

    Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, which trains noticing and disengaging from ruminative thought, reduces relapse in recurrent depression in an individual patient data meta-analysis. Behavioral activation performs comparably to cognitive therapy and medication in acute depression. Trials directly testing these in combination with interventional treatments are limited.

    1. Kuyken et al. 2016, JAMA Psychiatry (meta-analysis)
    2. Dimidjian et al. 2006, J Consult Clin Psychol

What this picture simplifies

  • Three areas and one loop stand in for networks that span much of the brain.
  • The ring around the head is a metaphor for a repeating thought. Thoughts are not located in one place.
  • Group findings from brain imaging do not diagnose a person. Every person’s pattern is different.
  • Network changes are seen with treatment, but it is not settled that they cause people to feel better.

This guide is educational and does not replace a medical evaluation. The scene is an illustration and does not depict a patient.

The takeaway

  • Rumination is the same thought circling again and again.
  • In depression, the brain’s inward-looking network gets stuck in a loop.
  • Treatment aims to help your attention come back to the room.

What you can do next

  1. Notice when the loop starts, and name it.
  2. Tell your clinician how much of your day it takes.
  3. Request a consultation to ask what fits you.

If the same thoughts keep circling and nothing has helped

That is worth taking seriously. A first consultation is an evaluation, not a commitment to any treatment.

Or call us(571) 378-13986849 Old Dominion Drive, Suite 315, McLean
Call (571) 378-1398Request a consultation