How psychotherapy works alongside TMS, Spravato, ketamine and medicine, and why we encourage it.
Talk therapy alongside your treatment
Part 1 of 7
Therapy has come a long way since Freud.
Freud described depression as anger turned inward, and he treated it by uncovering what lay in the unconscious mind.
Since then, many other approaches have been developed and tested. Our understanding of depression has grown. One idea, called learned helplessness, is that after repeated setbacks a person stops expecting that anything they do will help.
Today there are several well-studied kinds of talk therapy for depression, and they work.
The evidence
Well established
Psychotherapies for depression have been tested in hundreds of randomized trials. In a network meta-analysis of trials in adults, psychotherapy and medication were similarly effective for response at the end of treatment.
Freud set out the idea of depression as loss and anger turned against the self in 1917. Seligman described learned helplessness in the 1960s and 1970s, and Beck developed cognitive therapy for depression in the same period.
Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) looks at how thoughts, feelings and actions are linked. The therapist looks closely at each one with you and helps you change the beliefs and habits that keep depression going.
Behavioral activation helps you rebuild a daily life with activities that bring meaning and enjoyment. Interpersonal therapy focuses on relationships, loss and life changes. Psychodynamic therapy looks at long-standing patterns and where they come from.
There are others. No single kind is right for everyone, and a good fit with your therapist counts for a lot.
The evidence
Well established
Cognitive behavioral therapy, behavioral activation, interpersonal therapy, psychodynamic therapy and problem-solving therapy all have randomized evidence in depression, with broadly similar average effects. Problem-solving therapy has been studied in particular in older adults.
Think of a computer. The hardware has to work: it needs power, memory and a working drive. The software has to work too: the operating system and each program. Now and then a program picks up a bug and needs an expert to debug it.
TMS, medicines, esketamine, ketamine, vagus nerve stimulation and ECT work on the hardware. Therapy works on the software.
A computer needs both to run well. So do people. These treatments are partners.
The evidence
Human evidence
In a network meta-analysis, combining psychotherapy with medication was more effective than either alone for response at the end of treatment (relative risk 1.27 against psychotherapy alone and 1.25 against medication alone).
The analogy is a teaching aid. Therapy also changes brain activity, and biological treatments also change how a person thinks and feels.
Our treatments can feel unfamiliar. If you already see a therapist regularly, that relationship gives you a familiar, steady place to talk through what you are experiencing.
We encourage you to keep going with therapy during treatment here. With your permission, we are glad to coordinate with your therapist.
The evidence
Human evidence
In a naturalistic study of 196 patients who received TMS together with psychotherapy based on cognitive behavioral therapy, 66% responded and 56% reached remission by the end of treatment. The study had no comparison group, so it cannot show how much the therapy added.
As depression lifts, energy and motivation come back. The next question is what to do with them.
A therapist can help you put that energy toward your goals, your daily functioning and your self-care. This is behavioral activation at work, at the moment you are most able to use it.
The evidence
Well established
Behavioral activation is an effective treatment for depression in its own right. Recovery of functioning, in work, relationships and daily life, is a central goal of treatment alongside relief of symptoms.
Therapists who work with our patients often find that sessions in the day or two after a ketamine or Spravato treatment are especially productive.
One explanation is that these medicines make the brain more open to change for a short time. Therapy during that window may help new patterns take hold.
If you can, schedule a therapy session for the day or two after your treatment.
The evidence
Leading modelEvidence mixed
Ketamine is thought to open a period of enhanced neuroplasticity, and researchers have proposed using it for cognitive and behavioral work. In a small randomized trial, 28 patients who responded to ketamine received cognitive behavioral therapy or usual care for 14 weeks. The therapy group did better, with a moderate-to-large effect, but the trial was too small for the result to be conclusive.
The observation about timing comes from clinical experience and has not been established in controlled trials.
Ketamine-assisted psychotherapy is an approach of its own. It begins with a preparation session. Then ketamine is given, by injection, by infusion, or as a lozenge that dissolves in the mouth, with the therapist present as a steady support.
The experience can bring up difficult material, including past trauma. Integration sessions follow, often the next day, to work through what came up.
This is still a developing field. Ask us what is available and whether it would suit you.
The evidence
Evidence mixed
Published protocols vary widely in route, dose, number of sessions and type of therapy. Systematic reviews report encouraging results from mostly uncontrolled studies, and call for larger randomized trials to show whether adding psychotherapy improves outcomes over ketamine alone.