Is it really bipolar disorder?

Bipolar disorder is serious, and it is specific. Moods that change from day to day are usually something else, and the difference changes the treatment.

Bipolar disorder, and what it is not

Part 1 of 10

Bipolar disorder is a serious, specific illness.

By definition it has two kinds of episodes: mania and depression.

Each episode is a distinct stretch of time, usually lasting days to weeks, in which a person is clearly different from their usual self.

The evidence
Well established

Bipolar I disorder requires at least one manic episode: a distinct period of abnormally elevated or irritable mood and increased energy lasting at least a week, or any duration if hospitalization is needed. Bipolar II requires hypomania of at least 4 days plus a major depressive episode.

  1. Merikangas et al. 2007, Arch Gen Psychiatry (prevalence)

Part 2 of 10

Mania is hard to miss.

Mood is unusually high or irritable. The person feels on top of the world, needs very little sleep, and is always on the go.

Thoughts race and speech is fast and hard to follow. Judgment slips: spending money they do not have, driving far too fast, or taking risks they would never usually take. Some people clean the house all night.

Other people notice, and often tell them to slow down.

The evidence
Well established

Manic episodes include grandiosity, decreased need for sleep, pressured speech, flight of ideas, distractibility, increased goal-directed activity and risky behavior, and represent a clear change from baseline that others can observe.

  1. Merikangas et al. 2007, Arch Gen Psychiatry (prevalence)

Part 3 of 10

Then, often, a crash.

After mania, many people fall into a depressive episode that lasts weeks or months.

Over a lifetime, most people with bipolar disorder spend far more time depressed than manic. That is one reason it can be confused with depression alone.

The evidence
Well established

Depressive episodes dominate the long-term course of bipolar disorder, and bipolar depression is frequently first diagnosed as unipolar depression before a manic or hypomanic episode is recognized.

  1. Merikangas et al. 2007, Arch Gen Psychiatry (prevalence)

Part 4 of 10

Moods that shift day to day are different.

Some people have moods that change within a day, or from one day to the next, often in response to stress, conflict or reminders of painful events.

This pattern is common after trauma, in complex PTSD and in borderline personality disorder. It is real, it is painful, and it is treatable.

It is not the same as bipolar disorder, and it calls for different treatment.

The evidence
Human evidence

Affective instability in borderline personality disorder and trauma-related conditions is typically reactive and lasts hours to a few days, in contrast to the sustained, episodic mood states of bipolar disorder. In one outpatient study, borderline personality disorder was the condition most strongly associated with an unconfirmed bipolar diagnosis.

  1. Ruggero et al. 2010, J Psychiatr Res (borderline personality and bipolar misdiagnosis)

Part 5 of 10

True bipolar disorder is uncommon.

About 1 in 100 people have bipolar I disorder, the form with full mania. About 1 more in 100 have bipolar II, the form with milder highs.

Depression is far more common.

The evidence
Human evidence

In a national US survey, lifetime prevalence was 1.0% for bipolar I and 1.1% for bipolar II. A further 2.4% had subthreshold symptoms that did not meet criteria for either.

  1. Merikangas et al. 2007, Arch Gen Psychiatry (prevalence)

Part 6 of 10

The wrong label can cost years.

Bipolar disorder and depression follow different treatment paths. A person given a bipolar label that does not fit may spend years on medicines meant for bipolar disorder, with side effects such as weight gain, and still not feel better.

The reverse also happens: bipolar disorder can be missed and treated as depression alone.

Either way, getting the diagnosis right comes first.

The evidence
Human evidence

In a study of 700 psychiatric outpatients, 145 reported a previous bipolar diagnosis, and fewer than half of them (43.4%) met criteria on a structured diagnostic interview. The authors concluded that overdiagnosis is a problem at least as large as underdiagnosis.

  1. Zimmerman et al. 2008, J Clin Psychiatry (overdiagnosis)

Part 7 of 10

How we sort it out.

We take a careful history of your moods over your whole life. We ask how long each change lasted, what set it off, how you slept, and what other people saw.

With your permission, we like to hear from someone who knows you well. We also ask about family history and about how you responded to past medicines.

The evidence
Human evidence

Structured, criterion-based assessment improves diagnostic accuracy. Family history of bipolar disorder supported the interview-based diagnosis in the outpatient study, and collateral history helps establish whether discrete episodes occurred.

  1. Zimmerman et al. 2008, J Clin Psychiatry (overdiagnosis)

Part 8 of 10

What it means for treatment.

If you have bipolar disorder, mood-stabilizing medicine is the foundation, and antidepressants are used with care.

If you do not, treatments for depression may be open to you that were being held back, including antidepressants, TMS and Spravato.

Do not stop or change a medicine on your own. If you have doubts about your diagnosis, ask for a careful second look.

The evidence
FDA labeling / guidelines

Spravato is approved for treatment-resistant major depressive disorder, and TMS is cleared for major depressive disorder. Neither is approved for bipolar depression, so an accurate diagnosis determines which options apply.

  1. Spravato (esketamine) prescribing information

Part 9 of 10

Can these treatments trigger mania?

In a person with bipolar disorder, any treatment that lifts depression can sometimes tip mood into mania. This is called a switch. It is uncommon, and it is disruptive when it happens, so we take it seriously.

In controlled studies of TMS, switches were no more common with real treatment than with sham treatment. Small controlled studies of ketamine found the same.

Spravato has not yet been tested against placebo in bipolar disorder. Real-world reports from the first weeks of treatment are reassuring. Over months of ongoing treatment, some people with bipolar disorder have had manic symptoms, which is why follow-up continues.

The evidence
Evidence mixed

Across 53 randomized trials of TMS for depression, treatment-emergent mania or hypomania occurred in 0.84% of active and 0.73% of sham patients, a difference that was not statistically significant. In sham-controlled trials limited to bipolar depression, a switch occurred in 1 of 106 active and 1 of 75 sham patients.

In a placebo-controlled crossover trial of ketamine added to lithium or valproate, one participant developed manic symptoms on ketamine and one on placebo. These trials were small and enrolled people who were already taking a mood stabilizer and had no manic symptoms at entry.

A systematic review of ketamine in bipolar depression counted hypomanic or manic symptoms in 6 of 235 participants (about 2%) across 8 studies, most of them uncontrolled. In one repeated-infusion study, 4 of 66 participants had a hypomanic switch.

For esketamine, a naturalistic study of 35 people with bipolar treatment-resistant depression found no treatment-emergent switch. In a real-world cohort of 45 people given ketamine or esketamine, none switched during the first four weeks, and 13 (29%) had hypomanic or manic symptoms at some point during maintenance, one of them needing hospital care. A large records-based comparison of 2,126 matched patients found no higher switch risk with esketamine plus a mood stabilizer than with a mood stabilizer alone; that study was observational.

  1. Xia et al. 2008, Int J Neuropsychopharmacology (mania in TMS trials)
  2. McGirr et al. 2016, Bipolar Disorders (TMS in bipolar depression)
  3. Diazgranados et al. 2010, Arch Gen Psychiatry (ketamine in bipolar depression)
  4. Fancy et al. (ketamine for bipolar depression, systematic review)
  5. Martinotti et al., REAL-ESK Study Group (esketamine in bipolar treatment-resistant depression)
  6. Santucci et al. (ketamine and esketamine in bipolar depression, real-world cohort)

Part 10 of 10

How we watch for it.

We settle the diagnosis first. If you have bipolar disorder, mood-stabilizing medicine stays in place during treatment.

At your visits we ask about your sleep, your energy and your mood.

Tell us right away if you are sleeping much less and do not feel tired, if your thoughts are racing, or if people close to you say you seem sped up.

The evidence
FDA labeling / guidelines

The controlled studies that found low switch rates kept participants on mood stabilizers, excluded current manic or mixed symptoms, and monitored with a mania rating scale. A reduced need for sleep is often the earliest sign of a switch.

  1. McGirr et al. 2016, Bipolar Disorders (TMS in bipolar depression)
  2. Santucci et al. (ketamine and esketamine in bipolar depression, real-world cohort)
1 of 10

Two different patterns over time

Bipolar disorderDistinct episodes that last days to weeks
ManiaDepression
Reactive mood shiftsChanges within hours or days, often with a trigger

A simplified picture across several weeks. Both patterns are real and treatable, in different ways.

Mania or hypomania in people with bipolar depression, by treatment

TMS1 of 106Sham TMS: 1 of 75. Controlled trials.
Ketamine, one infusion1 of 18Placebo: 1 of 18. One small controlled trial.
Ketamine, all studiesAbout 2 in 1006 of 235 people across 8 studies, most without a placebo group.
Spravato, first weeksNone reported35 people in one study and 45 in another. No placebo group.
Ketamine or Spravato, ongoing13 of 45At some point during months of maintenance, in one clinic.

Almost everyone in these studies was also taking a mood stabilizer and had no manic symptoms at the start. The studies are small.

Questions we ask

  • How long did the high last?
  • How much did you sleep?
  • Did other people notice?
  • Was there a trigger?
  • Does bipolar disorder run in your family?

Tell us right away

  • Sleeping much less, and not tired
  • Racing thoughts
  • Others say you seem sped up
  • Spending or risk-taking that is not like you

Both are treatable

Bipolar disorderTreatableMood-stabilizing medicine is the foundation
Reactive mood shiftsTreatableTherapy leads, with treatment for depression when it is present

This guide is for education and is not medical advice. It cannot tell you whether you have bipolar disorder. Do not stop or change a medicine without talking with your prescriber.

The takeaway

  • Bipolar disorder means distinct episodes of mania and depression that last days to weeks.
  • Moods that shift from day to day are real and treatable, and they are usually not bipolar disorder.
  • The diagnosis decides the treatment path, so it is worth getting right.

What you can do next

  1. Write down when your mood changes began and how long each one lasted.
  2. Ask someone who knows you well what they have seen.
  3. Bring your questions to a consultation. Do not stop a medicine on your own.

Ready to take the next step?

Your first consultation is an evaluation, not a commitment to any treatment. Our patient advocate calls you back within one business day.

Or call us(571) 378-13986849 Old Dominion Drive, Suite 315, McLean

Read our reviews on Google

Call (571) 378-1398Request a consultation